NCORR requests $220 million to complete its work by year-end

The North Carolina Office of Recovery and Resiliency (NCORR) expects it will take $220 million in additional state funds to complete work by the end of 2025 on 1,150 homes damaged by hurricanes Matthew and Florence. Another 39 homes might not be completed due to “atypical” circumstances.

NCORR Director Pryor Gibson testified before the Joint Commission on Governmental Operations Subcommittee on Hurricane Response and Recovery for nearly two and a half hours on January 30. Jonathan Krebs, advisor to Gov. Josh Stein on western North Carolina recovery, and Stephanie McGarrah, deputy secretary in the Division of Community Revitalization at the Department of Commerce, followed Gibson. They have been invited back before the committee to provide more details March 6.

The Subcommittee held its first hearing with NCORR in September 2022 when the agency was completing fewer than 10 homes per month. The federal government provided nearly $1 billion in three grants for NCORR to assist with the Eastern North Carolina storms. In October 2024, however, Gibson alerted legislators that NCORR had overcommitted funds by $175 million and would need state money to complete its work.

A more thorough accounting by the Office of State Budget and Management before the November 18, 2024, hearing showed NCORR had unmet needs of $320 million, which Gibson circuitously confirmed at the time. Legislators appropriated $30 million in November and another $50 million in December to get NCORR into February. Gibson said contractors may abandon the program without a firm commitment from the General Assembly before the end of February.

Co-chair Rep. Brenden Jones (R-Columbus) set an expectation for clear answers at the beginning of the hearing.

“No more excuses, no more delays, no more vague estimates, no more NCORR kicking the can down the road,” Rep. Jones said. “Today, as we go through this, we’re going to ask you how much money is actually needed to finish the operation. I’m going to ask you why we should believe you.”

Inconsistencies in the Gibson’s presentation over the number of employees, specific costs, and NCORR’s communication to general contractors further eroded subcommittee members’ trust and increased their frustration.

NCORR completed 143 homes in December and its latest report to Gov Ops staff showed 116 homes completed in the 30 days through January 29. In contrast, NCORR only issued 19 notices to proceed (NTPs) in that time and had not issued a contract since December 19 (see graph). 

NCORR Deficit is $100 Million Larger than Acknowledged

Leadership of the North Carolina Office of Recovery and Resiliency (NCORR) gave incomplete responses to pointed questions from members of the Joint Legislative Commission on Governmental Operations Subcommittee on Hurricane Response and Recovery during the November 18 hearing.

On the agency’s funding need, which her presentation and press reports inaccurately pegged at $221 million, (now former) NCORR Director Laura Hogshead said, “Worst case scenario is the $264 million number… if there’s no attrition or not able to use any other sources of funding.” But that figure did not include any contingency for higher construction costs for any of the roughly 1,400 homes still to be completed. From a spreadsheet NCORR provided to the subcommittee, building in a contingency would bring the remaining unmet need to $289 million, on top of $30 million appropriated by the General Assembly in October.

Governor Roy Cooper’s Deputy Legislative Counsel Pryor Gibson, who appeared before the subcommittee with Hogshead, first told legislative leadership about NCORR’s $289 million need on October 21, two days before the chambers were to vote on assistance to the western counties devastated by Hurricane Helene.

By 2021, NCORR budgeted $534 million of $982 million in federal funds for hurricanes Matthew and Florence to repair and rebuild homes in its Homeowner Recovery Program (HRP.) Since then, NCORR has transferred $148 million in additional funds from other purposes in that federal pot to bring the total for repairs and reconstruction to $683 million. The latest estimate for HRP is $980 million, which leaves, along with NCORR’s other spending on Matthew and Florence, a deficit of $319 million.

Hogshead acknowledged to Rep. Brenden Jones (R-Columbus, Robeson) that she did not raise flags as the program took on more than it could cover because, while staff were monitoring individual line items, no one was monitoring at the overall budget. Although she took the blame for it, Hogshead refused to resign.

While NCORR’s financial problems prompted the hearing, much of the time was spent looking back at the agency’s other problems and looking ahead to potential responses to Hurricane Helene. Gibson promised better financial reporting to the legislature, and members remained skeptical about providing more money to NCORR. Rep. Jones closed with a touching personal note about the people he and other members see every day who are counting on state government to fulfill its promises without delay.

Troubles Ongoing for Onslow County Family

Sonya Black and her family live in an RV behind their house. They boil water for cooking and bathing. Their power comes from drop cords connected to a breaker box on a specially installed power pole in their backyard.

Sonya Black and her family have lived in an RV since 2019.

Black and her family of five lived in a hotel for eight months after Hurricane Florence. When that became infeasible financially and logistically, the family moved into an RV that friends donated to them. They have been living there ever since. “We were preparing to go to a homeless shelter because we ran out of money,” she said. “It’s like camping. We’re living out of suitcases.”

“We’re going to see what we can do to get things moving ahead,” Rep. Phil Shepard said as he listened to the Blacks’ experience in the storm and since. “Sometimes it’s just people realizing that people are watching what’s going on.”

The Blacks had evacuated before the storm, but its evidence was abundant. Sonya said, “We came back two weeks later, and everything had already mildewed and molded over.”

Sonya and her husband together described the damage from the storm. “It rained hard for a complete week,” she said. “The shingles never blew off, but the rain went under the shingles, saturated everything inside.”

“It never broke the shingles; they laid back down,” her husband James added. “There was no physical or visual damage you could see to the roof.”

“Then the ceilings fell,” Sonya continued. “Ceilings fell in the sewing/craft room, the living room, and the kitchen. The den had gotten wet from where the water had permeated through, and it flooded five feet in the basement. The sump pump went out because the power went out. “

They tore down walls themselves and hired a rapid-response disaster company to dry out the home.

A contractor they hired to do repairs took the money and left the house unfinished. The Blacks learned that the contractors were fraudulent, but they ultimately decided not to sue. Instead, Sonya and James started a GoFundMe page to replace the insulation and the floors in their home and simultaneously applied to the ReBuild NC program. Once approved, they were told they had to stop working on their home. Now, almost three years later, they are still waiting for their repair work to go to bid.

The (now) six members of the family are doing what they can to manage until work begins on their home and they are eligible for Temporary Relocation Assistance. Two sons live with Sonya and James in the RV, and one of them took a job at Chick-fil-A to help with finances. Their daughter and grandson are living in Virginia because there’s no room in the RV. Sonya is operating her soap-making business out of a shed on their property. “It’s half the size of the basement I used to work in,” she said. “Plus, I lost the room in the house I used as a store.”

Sonya is clearly exasperated. “There needs to be better organization when it comes to ReBuild NC,” she said. “We kept calling, and we would only get ‘waiting on approval.’ Give me something better than that. What are you waiting on? It’s things like that that have us frustrated and have lost trust because we’re a family of six doing everything that we can, and it’s hard.”

She added: “I’m ready for it to be over. All we’re waiting on is sheetrock. Why is it taking so long? They have floors and materials from their GoFundMe, all we need is help to make it happen.”

“There needs to be better organization

when it comes to Rebuild NC”

Sonya Black